English Language Arts6-8
Character Change TDA Outline Using Say, Mean, Matter
By Elizabeth N.
A scaffolded outline for 6th grade learning support students to plan a Text-Dependent Analysis essay on how the narrator of "The Cormorant in My Bathtub" changes. It uses the Say, Mean, Matter structure to help students pull direct quotes, explain them in their own words, and connect them to the character's growth.
Customize for your classroom
Teacher Guide & Tips
- Use this outline as a guided planning tool before students draft their TDA, pairing it with a short whole-class read of the story and a model paragraph from the Say, Mean, Matter example.
- Discussion question: How does the narrator's first encounter with the oil-covered birds change how she sees herself and her place in the community?
- Scaffold for struggling readers: Provide a sentence starter for each part ("The text says...," "This means...," "This matters because...") and a word bank of character-change vocabulary such as isolated, responsible, and connected.
- Extension for advanced students: Ask them to compare the narrator's change with the cormorant's recovery and explain how the two parallel each other in the story's theme.
- Estimated time: About 45 minutes for the outline, plus one or two class periods for drafting the full essay.
English Language Arts6-8
Character Change TDA Outline Using Say, Mean, Matter
By Elizabeth N.
A scaffolded outline for 6th grade learning support students to plan a Text-Dependent Analysis essay on how the narrator of "The Cormorant in My Bathtub" changes. It uses the Say, Mean, Matter structure to help students pull direct quotes, explain them in their own words, and connect them to the character's growth.
Customize for your classroom
Teacher Guide & Tips
- Use this outline as a guided planning tool before students draft their TDA, pairing it with a short whole-class read of the story and a model paragraph from the Say, Mean, Matter example.
- Discussion question: How does the narrator's first encounter with the oil-covered birds change how she sees herself and her place in the community?
- Scaffold for struggling readers: Provide a sentence starter for each part ("The text says...," "This means...," "This matters because...") and a word bank of character-change vocabulary such as isolated, responsible, and connected.
- Extension for advanced students: Ask them to compare the narrator's change with the cormorant's recovery and explain how the two parallel each other in the story's theme.
- Estimated time: About 45 minutes for the outline, plus one or two class periods for drafting the full essay.